| Elissa Palermo | 2023, 2024 | Homer Stevenson* | 1958, 1959 | |
| Catherine Simon-Vobornik | 2021, 2022 | Emerson K. Houser* | 1957 | |
| Jonathan Zivojnovic | 2019, 2020 | John G. Hoppe, Sr.* | 1956 | |
| John Lawrence | 2017, 2018 | Ray J. Caron* | 1955 | |
| Jane McClelland | 2015, 2016 | John F. Pilgrim* | 1954 | |
| Andy Gagliardo | 2013, 2014 | Arthur G. Larsen* | 1953 | |
| Michael O’Neill | 2011, 2012 | James H. Rhode* | 1952 | |
| Ramona Fox | 2009, 2010 | W.C. Warman* | 1951 | |
| Gary Mancuso | 2007, 2008 | Earl T. Marquardt* | 1949, 1950 | |
| Richard C. Gloor | 2005, 2006 | James M. Robinson* | 1948 | |
| Steven Nasralla | 2003, 2004 | David Decker* | 1947 | |
| Jamie Hogan | 2001, 2002 | Graeme Stewart* | 1946 | |
| Jack Strand | 1999, 2000 | James F. Martinek* | 1945 | |
| Stephen Warden | 1997, 1998 | Edwin Forkel* (completed term) | 1944 | |
| Joan Filbin | 1996 | John F. Pilgrim* (entered Armed Forces) | 1944 | |
| W. Robert James, Jr.* | 1994, 1995 | Herrick R. Goodwillie* | 1943 | |
| John E. O’Neill* | 1992, 1993 | Lee M. Krafft* | 1942 | |
| Gabe Caporale | 1990, 1991 | Sanborn O. Houser* | 1941 | |
| Robert Buttny* | 1988, 1989 | Cora Wright* | 1940 | |
| Mary Jane Oliver | 1986, 1987 | Tiny A. Sumner* | 1939 | |
| Alan J. Rossell | 1984, 1985 | Walter R. James* | 1938 | |
| Irene K. Frank* | 1982, 1983 | Homer L. Bundy* | 1937 | |
| Thomas Cusack, Jr.* | 1980, 1981 | Don W. Riley* | 1936 | |
| Gilbert L. Houston* | 1978, 1979 | Harry E. Hopkins* | 1935 | |
| Alfred H. Gallagher* | 1976, 1977 | Rudy W. Bramberg* | 1934 | |
| A. Richard Gloor, Jr.* | 1974, 1975 | James A. Howe* | 1933 | |
| W. Robert James, Jr.* | 1972, 1973 | George C. Bruckert* | 1932 | |
| Sam R. Ciccio* | 1970, 1971 | John C. Lindhop* | 1931 | |
| John J. Sprafka* | 1968, 1969 | Edwin H. Forkel* | 1930 | |
| Joseph A. Gagliardo* | 1967 | Ralph Cook* | 1929 | |
| John J. Walsh, Jr.* | 1966 | Cary Debutts* | 1928 | |
| Willis F. Whitaker* | 1965 | Ted R. Leth* | 1927 | |
| James D. VanDoren* | 1964 | Thomas B. Roberts* | 1926 | |
| Wendell T. Hegg* | 1963 | James A. Kelly* | 1925 | |
| John F. Butler, Jr.* | 1962 | Warren T. Easter* | 1924 | |
| Joseph Reichmann* | 1961 | Ralph Skillin* | 1923 | |
| Albert R. Gloor* | 1960 | Wilbur H. Wright* | 1922 | |
| George R. Hemingway* | 1921 | |||
| James A. Feron* | 1920 | |||
| James A. Kelly* | 1919 | |||
| George L. Bruckert* | 1918 | |||
| Edward H. Duff* | 1917 | |||
| *Deceased |
